A lot of my students get their wisdom teeth cut out. You’ve seen the videos where they talk crazy, right? I’m Gen X and I went to an old-school dentist in the tiny town of Inman, SC. I had the same dentist from birth through my 30s. He was hilarious and he loved to joke with me when I came in – which was pretty often. My teeth are kinda terrible. I didn’t grow up with fluoride in my water since we had a well. Pair that with my intense love of candy and a steady flow of soft drinks and you end up with a mouth full of fillings. In the 1980s and 1990s, those fillings were all some sort of toxic metal and I had enough metal in there that when I stuck a spoon in my mouth, I could get radio signals from Russia in my head. Then science discovered all that metal was actually toxic and I had to get all those fillings removed and replaced by whatever the newest, less toxic thing was. So much drilling, so much Novocain and so many trips to visit my dentist.
I also had 4 wisdom teeth and two of those had erupted from the gumline in a way that was crowding my other teeth. No big deal to Dr. Beachamp. He said we’d just pull those suckers out. He shot me full of Novocain, grabbed some dental pliers, put his foot on my shoulder and yanked those puppies out. I may be exaggerating the foot on my shoulder, but I’m not joking when I tell you he was asking me to pull against him as he used all his body weight to pull those teeth out.
I was in my early 20s when he did this and I never once thought he didn’t know what he was doing. It never occurred to me to stop him and ask him to explain why he was pulling my teeth the way he was. I grew up working in my dad’s welding shop and I had used pliers a lot in my 20 years. I never considered telling my dentist that he wasn’t holding the pliers correctly or telling him I had a better idea for getting my teeth out. I mean, that would have been silly, right? Like, actually ridiculous.
I was thinking about this recently when a student questioned me about my teaching. A couple of students, actually, have done that this academic year and it’s not uncommon. I would say that at least once a year, I have one or two students who will ask me to stop what I’m doing and explain to them the exact nature of my pedagogy. They don’t understand why I’m making certain choices in my teaching, they think they know a better way and they demand an explanation.
At my age, I’m not very patient. Now that I’m 54 I figure I can play my age card and just not tell people I was never patient at all. After 24 years teaching college level studio art classes, I feel safe saying I know what I’m doing. Sure, students have changed and so has the educational climate, but I have kept up. I pay attention and I’m a very driven teacher, so I have adapted my teaching to continue to be successful in these very different academic times. Because of that, when a student asks me to slow down and explain my every decision, I just don’t have the patience to oblige. Most recently, I will respond with something along the lines of “I’m asking you to trust me”. I figure if the student doesn’t trust the professor, we’re pretty much done being productive anyway.
See, I know that Dr. Beachamp went to school for some extra years to become a dentist. I understand that school involves some book learning, but that he also had to spend a lot of time practicing his craft before he earned his degree. I also knew that as a middle aged man when I met him, he had extensive hands-on experience at being a dentist. Dude had seen some teeth and worked on them, you know? As a child and even as a 20 year old, I had not been to dental school, nor had I worked on teeth for a decade or so. He was the expert in the room when it came to teeth.
At this point in my teaching career, I’ve been teaching studio art classes longer than most of my students have been alive. They are either fresh out of high school or in their undergraduate years and most don’t even have fully developed frontal lobes. Absolutely none have teaching experience at the college level. Not even a semester. The idea of having to stop my class and explain to them why I’m making the choices I’m making is just as ridiculous as questioning any other professional. I just don’t understand it.
I didn’t like getting my gums shot full of Novocain. I didn’t like getting my teeth drilled. I didn’t like the Doc jerking my teeth out with all of his body weight. Still, I didn’t blame him for what needed to be done. I didn’t question it because I had zero understanding of dentistry. He said something needed to be done and I said, “Ok”. No discussion, no questions.
What is it about the current climate of education that causes teachers to be treated so differently from all other professionals? University professors have annual reviews, intense 3 and 6 year reviews and our course evaluations from students are treated like sacred religious texts, often quoted or otherwise referenced in our annual reviews. At any moment, we are expected to explain exactly what we are doing, why we are doing it and then we are expected to politely explain why the students’ “better ideas” aren’t actually better ideas without insulting them or hurting their feelings. It makes no sense.
A K-12 teacher must have a degree, pass the Praxis and be certified by the state. It seems like those achievements would merit some sort of trust and respect. A university teacher must earn the terminal degree in their field of study. Not only are they expected to be experts in the area of study, but also in the practice of teaching. Again, they are reviewed annually and observed in the classroom on various occasions to ensure competency. Why can’t we trust them?
When the decisions affecting education are being made outside of the teaching institution and being made by people who have never taught in the educational system, you should expect those decisions to be pretty terrible for education.
If you’ve ever wondered why public education is in the state it’s currently in, maybe you should be asking why we don’t trust teachers to do their jobs and why we don’t elect former teachers to make educational policies.




