Part 3: Literally, the Bible (and life)
Outside of my own childhood echo chamber, I had the freedom to read the Bible without bias. Ok, that’s not completely true, I was definitely still biased. Twenty or so years of indoctrination is hard to shake. But as I read the Bible and engaged with the questions, I now had the space to allow that cognitive dissonance to breathe and even expand. I actually had a funny experience in my final run of teaching Sunday School to adults that became a help to me.
Somehow I was asked to be a Sunday School teacher on a monthly rotation. This must have been 15 or more years ago. I taught one Sunday each month to a married couples’ class. At this point, I was still on the outskirts of the Baptist echo chamber, but I saw this role as a way to encourage other adults to ask their own questions and perhaps even nudge them towards the outskirts themselves. I had complete freedom in what I taught and I took full advantage of that. One particular lesson I taught was about the importance of questions when it comes to faith and how those questions can help you move toward an even stronger faith. I used the many questions of Jesus to illustrate the value of questions over answers.
There were several members of the class who were very supportive of my different approach to these lessons. A few of them let me know how much they appreciated my perspective that day. The following Sunday, a different, more conventional teacher in the rotation built a lesson off of my lesson, stressing the importance of “things you should NEVER question”. I found it pretty hilarious and while I did not agree with this teacher’s take on questions, I did find it interesting that they included “the virgin birth” in their lesson as something we should never question. I mean, how could you not question that? That lesson had the opposite intended effect on me as I then began to wonder why the virgin birth was a necessary part of Christian church doctrine. I don’t have an answer yet, by the way, and that’s ok.
Not long after that, a new “Minister of Education” came on staff and when he found out our Sunday School class was just doing their own thing without using any of the provided teaching materials, he shut us down and brought in a new teacher. That's how you keep the echo going.
I read the Bible through way back in the day and then did it again when a church we attended as a family did a shared read-through of the Chronological Bible. That one really opened some doors of thought for me. Rethinking the authorship and timeline of the structure of the Bible allowed me to look for outside sources for information. How old were these texts? What languages were they originally written in? What was the intended purpose for writing them down and then eventually choosing them to be a part of the Biblical canon?
(That pastor did his best to use his Sunday morning sermons to address any cognitive dissonances that arose during the scheduled weekly readings. Again, this had the opposite intended effect on me as I roundly dismissed his explanations and let my own questions linger. Angels were having sex with humans and created a race of giants? Really? (Genesis 6:2)
Once you begin to see the entire Biblical document as a work of literature instead of a finished book handed from God to Moses (or your local minister) things have the ability to change a bit. Anything that man is involved in can get tangled. I remember a youth minister telling me that while the text was written by man, it was inspired by God and God was powerful enough to make sure that the text remained unchanged and pure over the course of time. That made sense to me as a person who already believed God was much larger and more powerful that we had made him in our heads.
Then I learned how the King James Version of the Bible was written and translated. I find it very funny when many small, fire and brimstone churches here in the South talk about the KJV like it was a digital recorder straight from God. I know people who refuse to go to churches that use other translations. Sadly, these people haven’t stepped outside of their echo chambers long enough to know that the KJV was actually just a bad combination of the traditional Biblical translations mixed with margin notes from translators and scholars and then put to a nice little Shakespearean accent in a way that was 100% designed to not upset the King of England, who was paying for it.
When I learned this, there was more cognitive dissonance. How can the Bible be the inspired “Word of God” and be tampered with by man? How do you figure out which is which, I mean, without having your own certificate of Biblical scholarship from a renowned university?
And what about that “canon” I mentioned earlier? Some readers of the Bible are not aware that the books and verses that make up the particular Bible they are holding were chosen from a much larger collection of books and verses that humans had viewed as “the inspired Word of God” for hundreds or thousands of years. Some dudes got together and decided to evict some of those books. Some books had chunks of chapters or verses modified or deleted over the years due to discrepancies in different copies of the same text. I’m not saying the Bible isn’t great or even inspired, I just think it’s important to know something about the origin of a book if you’re going to base your entire belief system and life on it.
There’s also the thing that is popular here in the South and in Southern Baptist doctrine about the Bible being interpreted literally. I used to get the gist of what they meant, or I thought I did, but what do you do with literality when you’re dealing with a document that contains a large amount of poetry and stories that are clearly parables or illustrations? Come on, Solomon, or other ghost writers of the Song of Songs, were her breasts literally two deer in a meadow? Metaphor is a thing and has been for a long time.
Speaking of the Song of Songs/Solomon, why do we have a bunch of middle eastern erotic poetry in our sacred book if the entire neighborhood of Protestantism is so ashamed of and afraid to talk about sex? See? Questions are important. Questions are a necessary part of education. Just remember, education is bad because it can make you too liberal. (Satire for those of you not really paying attention.)
In addition to the Bible, I also absorbed a lot of other written thoughts on spirituality and religion. My bookshelf would have you believe I’m an ordained minister. Which is funny, because I actually am, we just don’t talk about that unless you want me to officiate your wedding. Donald Miller was an early favorite as a spiritual writer. His book “Blue Like Jazz” woke up a part of my recovering Southern Baptist brain forever. Before podcasts were really a thing, I downloaded and listened to sermons by Rob Bell and devoured his books. If you’re still living inside the echo chamber, you might see those names and say, “well, of course, you have terrible beliefs, those are liberal people”, but I also read Francis Chan and other hardcore conservative writers. And, as a good Southern Baptist youth, I grew up on a healthy diet of James Dobson, Tim LaHaye and Philip Yancey so I definitely needed some free-thinkers to balance that out.
So I read both the Bible and other spiritually themed books but I will argue that my more recent thoughts and beliefs about the Bible did not come solely from the questions raised by those. Some of what I currently believe comes from the experience of living life. I’m not sure I can explain this well, but let’s give it a try.
As I have lived through a lot of Mondays and Thursdays and Saturday mornings as a human, I have felt a lot of emotions and had a lot of thoughts. I’ve interacted with other humans and enjoyed friendships, benefitted from community and I’ve also seen some really bad behavior. I’ve had brushes with narcissists, ego-maniacs and people who were just plain mean for no reason. Having to learn how to safely interact with these people while also understanding that some of those negative qualities will certainly sometimes surface in my own actions, forces me to consider how my life is a part of a larger society and human experience. I have felt, for lack of a better example, that I am working as a small part in a much larger human machine, seemingly for some larger purpose. Some of these feelings align perfectly in my head with a few of the teachings of Jesus that are recorded in the Bible.
In my highest highs and lowest lows as a human, I have never felt alone. Lived experience has convinced me of a presence that feels like warmth and softness and love. I have no historical documents or scientific data to prove that presence to you, and I very much do not need the proof because I have felt it. I realize how unspecific this description may be, but feeling that very real presence in the world is the best reason I have found to date, to believe that God exists. And that’s where magic comes into my worldview.


